Photography exhibition censored in New Delhi [update]

sun-city-print-601-web

"Untitled, from the series 'Sun City', 2011" © Sunil Gupta/Vadehra Art Gallery, New Delhi

Photographer Sunil Gupta has seen his Sun City and Other Stories exhibition shut down after the police received complaints over the content of his work. Gupta speaks to BJP

Author: Olivier Laurent

Late last month, the Alliance Française in New Delhi closed down an exhibition of Indian born and UK-based photographer Sunil Gupta's work after the organisation received a complaint over the content of Gupta's images.

The work, dubbed Sun City and Other Stories, depicts the double life of a homosexual man. "He alternates between livign out a romantic relationship above ground or in the open, and another life where he discovers the gay bath house and slowly progresses towards increasing degrees of intimacy with a series of anonumous partners," writes Gupta.

The work is "a fictional narrative loosely based on the 1962 film La Jetée by Chris Marker," he adds. "We can view it as some 'stills' from a film that is 'missing' The original elliptical form has been retained so the 'hero' sees his own death in the 'beginning' and we return to that scene as reality in the 'end'."

Sun City was commissioned by the Centre Pompidou in Paris and selected by Alliance Française to appear in its New Delhi gallery. However, says the artist, on opening day, the police received a complaint over the content of Gupta's images, that resulted in Alliance Française closing down the exhibition.

Speaking to BJP, Gupta explains what happened:"During the opening night, the exhibition was visited by the police as someone had complained to them that obscene material was on display. They asked for all the bathhouse pictures to be taken down. A request that was complied with on the spot by the management of the venue, the Alliance Française de Delhi. As the exhibition comprised of three series of works, including "Sun City" which involved the bath house pictures, I was surprised when the AF decided to close the show in it's entirety without giving any reason."

He continues: "A few days later the story broke in the Delhi newspapers and the police were quoted that there were not bringing charges and that they had nothing against the exhibition. Upon hearing this news, Safdar Hashmi Memorial Trust, a local artists activist organisation sent the AF an open letter demanding an explanation or else to face a boycott of the institution. This was signed by several leading contemporary artists and gallerists in Delhi."

At that point, the Alliance Française invited Gupta to remount the exhibition. "But this time they didn't even allow it to open," he says. "After a couple of days I decided to take down the work as it seemed silly to have the exhibition locked up. Finally this weekend the AF did issue a statement saying that they were intimidated by the police, etc. But what is worrying is that there were actually no charges filed and that a gallery shut a show down on the pretext of 'sensitivities to local culture.' The artists' are not impressed with the gallery's late and rather inadequate response.

According to a report published by Pink News, Alliance Française said: "The decision to shut down the exhibition was taken by the director [of Alliance Française] unanimously with the artist. The opening of the exhibition, held on Friday, was a private affair and during the opening only it was decided that we will not continue with the exhibition."

In a statement released to the press and published by Pink News, the Safdar Hashmi Memorial Trust, which campaigns for the arts, says: "If major institutions like the Alliance Française cannot stand up against complaints made by a single individual and support the work of an artist they have invited to exhibit, they do not deserve the respect or patronage of the art community. We hope the Alliance will clarify the circumstances which have led to yet another instance of moral policing against the freedom of expression."

  • Comment
  • Print
  • RSS
  • LinkedIn

Comments

News?

As, apparently,

"The decision to shut down the exhibition was taken by the director [of Alliance Française] unanimously with the artist." and that "The opening of the exhibition ... was a private affair and during the opening ... it was decided ... not [to] continue with the exhibition."

Is this really 'news'?

Posted by: Dot on 19 Apr 2012 at 13:11

Changing Times

As an openly gay man of 40, I have seen a lot of changes, in other countries as well as Britain, in attitudes toasted homosexuality. I have enjoyed meeting and having Frank discussions with men of all ages, many who have been married, had kids, then changed into gay men. All this has greatly enhanced my understanding of this immensely complex area of life. It is in the realm of religion and religious sensibilities that you will find most reactionaries. I have been surprised time and again by the sheer broadmindedness of some really rough young men who, at first, appear to be really thuggish so, you would expect them to be dyed-in-the-wool queer- bashers. But no.

As far as this exhibition is concerned, it has the potential to bring the bath-house culture out into the open and show that, unlike with smelly gents lavatories, there is nothing seedy about it. After all, dad does not want to take his little boy into the public lavatories in the park only to be confronted with men playing about with each other, in one way or another. However, the bath-house is another story.

Posted by: Dave Murray on 19 Apr 2012 at 18:07

out of touch?

I have not seejn the show. If you look at the included illustration, and then imagine in with women only, or with men and women together, done exactly the same way, it would in any of those three incarnations cause offence in India, Bangle Desh Afghanistan, Iran, Iraq, Syria, Jordan, Egypt, etcetera. It would be closed down very probably in all of those countries.

I can remember the India of 20 or so years ago. The Ramayana had been serialised and shown in colour on TV.

Although a love story it is as important a religious epic as our Bible. When shown on local TVs, people garlanded the TV sets with flowers and lit candles on either side of the television, and when after the series had ended, the actors went down the Ganges in Varanasi on boats, the women stars were abused and stoned because they, and especially Sita, were wearing jeans.

Nuf said?

Posted by: Peter Harrap on 19 Apr 2012 at 19:42

Statement of the Alliance Française Delhi regarding this issue.

Please refer to this statement: http://delhi.afindia.org/afdelhi-statement

Posted by: Jean-Philippe Bottin on 20 Apr 2012 at 14:58

Updating your subscription status Loading